10 Best Flies for Rainbow Trout: Tested Patterns for Dry Flies, Nymphs, and Streamers
|
|
|
Time to read 8 min
|
|
|
Time to read 8 min
Rainbow trout aren’t hard to catch, but their behavior can change quickly. Some days, they'll bite at anything you throw at them. Other times, they simply ignore every fly in your box except for a specific pattern and size. The trick is knowing which flies to reach for first.
If you want to improve your catch rate, this list gives you a clean starting point. We’ll share the 10 best flies for rainbow trout so you can avoid wasting time cycling through patterns that don’t match what trout want.
Let’s get started.
Parachute Adams, Pheasant Tail, and Zebra Midge are some of the best flies for rainbow trout. Knowing when to fish each pattern and which size to use helps you dial in what trout are eating, so you don’t spend half your day switching flies.
Here’s a quick guide to compare these flies side by side:
Fly Type |
Fly Pattern |
Sizes |
When to Use |
Dry Flies |
Parachute Adams |
12-18 |
Surface feeding, unsure which bug is hatching |
Elk Hair Caddis |
12-16 |
Evening hatches, rippled water |
|
Stimulator |
10-14 |
Fast creeks, prospecting |
|
Nymphs |
Pheasant Tail |
14-18 |
All-purpose, seams, and tailouts |
Hare's Ear |
12-16 |
Buggy profile, emergers |
|
Zebra Midge |
18-22 |
Cold water, tailwaters |
|
Rainbow Warrior |
16-20 |
Stained water, flash needed |
|
Streamers |
Woolly Bugger |
6-10 |
Big fish, low light |
Sculpin |
6-10 |
Bottom feeding, banks |
|
Slim Baitfish |
6-10 |
Lakes, slow retrieves |
As you fish these patterns, check what the rainbows are feeding on that day. Usually, mornings are perfect for dry flies, but by midday, the trout may stop rising. From there, you’ll want to switch to nymphs or streamers.
Now that you know about it, let’s go into each fly in more detail.
Dry fly fishing is about being visual and reactive. You see a rise, you cast, and the trout eats. If you are just starting, don’t worry. We suggest you check out our basic fly fishing skills guide to improve your casting and help you get more natural drifts.
Once you’re confident with it, take note of the best dry flies you can stock up on.
The Parachute Adams use stiff, buoyant hackles (typically from a rooster's neck) to imitate a dry or resting insect on the surface. It doesn’t mimic any one insect perfectly, but its “parachute” style fools trout into seeing it as a mayfly, a small caddis, or something edible floating by.
To choose the right size, we recommend 14-16 for most conditions. However, when the water is quiet and the trout are being picky, go down to 18. You can also adjust to 12 for rapid pocket water, where the trout don't have time to look closely.
Summer evenings on a river with caddis hatching everywhere are what trout fishing is all about. You can often hear trout slashing at them before you even see the rises. That's when you tie on an Elk Hair Caddis and get ready.
The elk hair wing is what makes this fly so effective. It keeps the fly floating even after multiple fish have hammered it. Color choices matter, and each one has a purpose:
Our best tip for fishing it is to cast close to banks, behind rocks, or anywhere you see rough water. Don’t be afraid to give it a gentle twitch, because caddis often skitter across the surface.
If you want to expand your caddis options, check out our caddis fly patterns collection for different sizes and color variations you can choose from. Experimenting with these will help you match the hatch more accurately and increase your chances of hooking more trout.
Late summer through fall is the terrestrial season. It is when grasshoppers, beetles, and crickets are constantly falling into the water. Trout recognize this immediately, that’s why we like using a Stimulator to imitate these meals.
In most situations, sizes 10-12 work perfectly. But if you're fishing fast pocket water with aggressive fish, bump up to a size 10. You can also use these as one of the strike indicators with a smaller nymph dropper underneath, which we’ll discuss in detail below.
For now, you can browse our complete dry flies collection to get an idea of the fly size and style you need.
Unlike dry flies or streamers, nymphs or wet flies allow you to target the trout’s feeding zone directly. Learning more patterns and how to fish them will help you put more fish in the net, even when the surface is calm and quiet.
Here, we list the best nymphs you can rely on most:
If you’re a beginner fly angler and have only one nymph, make it a Pheasant Tail. Why? Because it imitates a bunch of other subsurface bugs, mayfly nymphs, small caddis larvae, and more. That means you can fish it in almost any situation without bringing in many flies.
Here’s how to fish it: Dead-drift through riffles and runs where trout hold. If you need more depth, add a split shot above it. If that doesn’t work, fish it as the top fly in a two-nymph rig with a heavier fly below, like this Bead Head Prince Nymph.
Think of Gold Ribbed Hare's Ear as the “when in doubt” nymph. Its spiky dubbing and mottled tan-brown body give it a buggy appearance that imitates mayflies, caddis, or small stoneflies.
Also, its rough texture can trap tiny air bubbles underwater. This makes the fly look alive and natural, something smooth-bodied flies often lack.
When you drift this nymph through the feeding lanes, those small bubbles can hook the eye of a steelhead. It’s easy to use, which is why it deserves a spot in your nymphing arsenal.
Midges hatch year-round, even in winter when nothing else is coming off. Because of this, rainbows never stop feeding on them, which makes this Zebra Midge (size 18) one of the most reliable patterns for its thread-like body with a bead head.
Here’s how we fish it:
For advanced techniques that really improve your hookup rate with small nymphs like this, our euro nymphing setup guide breaks down rigging methods to increase your strike rate.
Same with other nymphs, Rainbow Warrior doesn’t look like any bug in nature, yet rainbows consistently take it. Its red wire body, pearl tinsel, and CDC wing signal “eat me” to trout.
You can fish it as your point fly in a two-nymph rig with something more natural above it, or by itself in faster water where rainbows are feeding aggressively. Its CDC wing is key here because it traps air and creates movement in the current that triggers strikes.
Note: None of the flies on this list use rubber legs, but some anglers like to pair them with Pat’s Rubber Legs. This adds extra, lively movement (especially in fast water) where trout react to quick, erratic motion.
Streamers are for bigger, aggressive trout. Now you’re no longer imitating bugs; you’re mimicking baitfish, leeches, or sculpins that trout want to chase down. Use streamers in high water, low light, or whenever trout are actively hunting.
Our top pick overall streamer is Woolly Bugger. Let’s find out why.
The Woolly Bugger is a marabou‑tail streamer that imitates leeches, minnows, crayfish, and big nymphs. Think of it as a “chameleon” in the water. It doesn’t perfectly match any single prey, but its buggy, lifelike movement is enough to convince trout that it’s an easy meal.
To ensure your catch, you should do these:
For fly fishers who are just starting, use this ready-to-use Woolly Bugger assortment with 15 flies included in a fly box. You can choose multiple sizes and colors in one package that lets you experiment until you find out which combinations work best.
Next up is Sculpin, a bottom-dwelling baitfish. Your sculpin pattern should have a wide head, tapered body, and pectoral fins that pulse in the current. Brown trout love these too, but aggressive rainbows won't pass them up.
You'll want to target rocky bottoms and drop-offs where sculpins naturally live. The key is mimicking how they move: strip it in short bursts to imitate a real sculpin darting away, then pause. That pause between strips is what triggers the strike most of the time.
Do we need to say anything more? This is the last, but one of our best bets. Slim Baitfish imitate small minnows that rainbows actively hunt in rivers and lakes. Its slim look cuts through the current, with flashy materials that catch light underwater.
What we like even more about Clouser Fly is their big, realistic eyes, which make them jig up and down, enough to trigger predatory instincts easily.
The best flies for rainbow trout include nymphs, midges, and dry flies like elk hair caddis or Adams. Choosing the right one depends on the specific water and conditions.
Start with size 14-16 for most water conditions. If you’re fishing calm and clear water, try smaller sizes between 18 and 22, and a larger 10-12 in fast or murky situations.
Rarely. During winter, rainbow trout tend to feed deeper on small nymphs because there aren't many bugs hatching. Use size 18-22 midges near the bottom for the best results.
Now, it’s time to get on the water and experiment. Choose 3-5 best flies for rainbow trout we’ve covered above for any trout situations, from creeks to freestone rivers and streams. The key is spending time on the water with them, not collecting 20+ flies you'll never use.
Ready to stock up? Wild Water Fly Fishing offers ready-to-use fly fishing lure kit sets that include the rainbow trout patterns we’ve covered in this guide.
All you need to do is pick the sizes that match the water you plan to fish, and you’ll be ready to catch fish without the guesswork. Reach out to us today at (585) 967-3474 for more details!
{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}